ideal tests for experimental economics (man whitney etc)

classic Classic list List threaded Threaded
1 message Options
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
Report Content as Inappropriate

ideal tests for experimental economics (man whitney etc)

This post has NOT been accepted by the mailing list yet.
Dear Statalisters,
I have done an economic experiment and  want to compare the two groups in terms of median, mean and whether they are coming from the same population etc.
I definitely do not feel comfortable about my knowledge about econometrics, so i need help about first what kind of tests are appropriate for my issue and how to interprete these tests.
I really always confused about the wording in econometrics, such as ' we fail to reject the null hypothesis'
So why dont we say that the null hypothesis is true, etc.
In my study:
Group A sample size is 17
Group B sample size is 18.
What can you suggest me about possible tests? which one to choose?
I did two of them allready,do you have more suggestions sich as KS test etc.
And i dont know how to interprete the results, I looked at the manuels but really i cant be sure whether I understood it correctly or not.
first one is median test, what is the formal name of this test in the literature, I can see from the command that it is testing the median but is there a formal name of the test which is related to the founders of the test, such as Man whitney.
1.). median offer, by(buyer)

Median test

   Greater |
  than the |         buyer
    median |         0          1 |     Total
        no |         9         10 |        19
       yes |         9          7 |        16
     Total |        18         17 |        35

          Pearson chi2(1) =   0.2743   Pr = 0.600

   Continuity corrected:
          Pearson chi2(1) =   0.0340   Pr = 0.854

What does the Pearson and continutity corrected tell me, are the two medians different or not.
Which one should I look, continutity correction or the one above.

2.)Another one is ranksum, but is this test same with U test, I am confused about the names, and the result interpretation

 ranksum offer, by(buyer)

Two-sample Wilcoxon rank-sum (Mann-Whitney) test

       buyer |      obs    rank sum    expected
           0 |       18         329         324
           1 |       17         301         306
    combined |       35         630         630

unadjusted variance      918.00
adjustment for ties       -9.26
adjusted variance        908.74

Ho: offer(buyer==0) = offer(buyer==1)
             z =   0.166
    Prob > |z| =   0.8683

What does the results say, are they coming from different distributions or not?
the means are different or not?

Thank you very much in advance.